This week I read this article written by Martha M.
Batalha, a Brazilian journalist who lives in New York and is pregnant of her
first child. I’m terribly sorry for my non-Portuguese speaking readers, because
the text is in Portuguese. But let me give you a small summary here. The article was written as
a letter addressed to the author's son in which she shares
her fears and frustrations on having to raise him in another country, far from
home. Her worst fear of all is that her son will be so integrated to the
American culture that he will be completely different from her and that that could
tear them apart in the future. In the letter she makes references to a lot
of things that were meaningful to her during her childhood in Rio de Janeiro.
And what makes her sad is to realize how different her son's childhood will be from hers. Nonetheless, she hopes to be able to show him and make him
understand the importance of where she comes from and therefore where he comes
from as well.
I was moved by the letter and I could identify myself with
the author in a lot of aspects. Not exactly in the exact same things that were
important during her childhood, because I wasn’t raised in Rio, but while I was
reading it I was able to make the connection with other things, sounds, places,
perfumes, people that were important to me while I was growing up and that my kids will
probably never know. In fact, the letter touched me so much that I couldn’t
stop thinking about it for the last few days and I kept thinking on how I positioned myself on
that particular subject.
The text brought back some dormant fears that I had during my first pregnancy. There were many. But most of them I
can’t even recall now, which probably means they weren’t that important.
Nonetheless, my worst fear of all was the language. I was afraid my children would
speak to me in English (or in Portuguese when we moved to Brazil). I don’t have
anything against those two languages. I’m fluent in both of them and I actually
like them a lot. But they are simply not mine. I don’t think in Portuguese nor
in English. Saying “I love you” in them would sound fake and getting angry
would not sound as effective as in French - the language I speak with my
children.
In my opinion, language is the biggest mark of a
person and a culture. In my case I’m totally divided, given that I’m bilingual
in French and Spanish. Depending on the situation I think in one or another. I
speak only French with my parents, my husband and my kids, but with a lot of
Spanish words here and there. I express my love to my kids with tender Spanish
words and I also curse in Spanish – this is my latino side, it always sounds
more poignant and dramatic. French is however more dominant in my daily life (Spanish is my sweetheart).
I’ve decided not to teach Spanish to my children. I
thought that French, Portuguese and English were enough for their little brains
for now. However, I sing to them in Spanish and I was amazed to see that they
can actually understand and sing along. I know that they will not be Spanish
speakers, but this is my way of transmitting a part of my culture to them. And
you can bet they’ll know and carry some Uruguayan cultural traces as well. They'll know that the best meat comes from there (sorry Daddy) and they'll certainly know that the best dulce de leche is Lapataia. In
fact, we are heading there for the Holidays and we’ll stay for almost a
month. They will never be Uruguayan, but they’ll learn how to like the country,
even if it is only through my eyes.
I sympathize with Martha when she says that her son
will never experience the things she liked when she was young. However, for me
this would always be a problem, given that I grew up in different countries.
How could they live the same life as I did if we would stay in only country? I
would love them to go each year to the market in Mexico City to choose their
own piñatas as I used to do. Or go to
Switzerland to celebrate L’éscalade
by breaking a chocolate pot. Or spend their vacations visiting grandparents in France and Italy. Don’t even let me started on all the things they
could be doing in Uruguay. And what about Brazil, where their father grew up? But I know that this is impossible.
However, I can teach them what my parents were able to
teach me. Values. I can teach them to respect and appreciate each and every
culture. I can teach them that they don’t necessarily need to agree with all
aspects of a certain country and that they can actually take advantage of their
diverse background to pick good things of all the cultures they are been exposed to and
make one of their own. The one we are creating at home. We read in French, English
and Portuguese. We watch DVDs in all three languages as well. A typical meal at
home could include pasta (my Italian side), arroz e feijão (rice and beans, typical of Brazil) or crêpes (with Uruguayan
dulce de leche of course). And this is normal. This is the way it has always been for me
and this is what I want to pass on.
No culture is better than the other and no country is
better than the other. I actually don't like when people start to become too nationalist. Probably because I can't understand what that means to love only one country, but also because it has always been at the root of any war. I believe that we can be happy and form a family anywhere in the World.
Besides your kids could have completely different experiences than yours even if you
stayed in one place all the time. Times have changed, the environment is different, and the parents of your children (you and your partner) are different than the ones you had. Education and values however should be the same. Our task is to guide our children. You can share the same culture as
your fellow citizens, but you know that what will always prevail is what you
were taught at home and the way you were raised. As parents of multicultural children, I believe that we have a quite challenging task ahead of us. Of course we want them to understand and respect where we and they come from. However, we have to be careful also not to alienate them from the local culture. We may not like everything, but we have to respect it.
When we moved back to Brazil, most of the people could not understand why I wanted so badly to come back to New York. Apartments are smaller, there is much less help than in Brazil and most importantly there is no family (I should also mention the winter). Agreed. It's not easy to be by yourself with two small kids and a husband away from home most of the time. But why wouldn't I want to come back to the only place in the world where for the first time in my life I didn't feel as a foreigner? For me New York is like a neutral place. People come
from all over the world. Speaking more than one language at home is almost the
norm. I love taking my kids to the playground and nobody looking at us because
we speak French (the way people used to look at us when we were in Brazil, with that look in their faces meaning "strange"). I love that F's classroom looks like a small U.N. summit. I love that I'm not the only foreigner in my building or at my Pilates class. I love that even the Americans who live here are not necessarily from here. I love having friends from all over the world. And I love the idea that my children are exposed to all this diversity and are part of it.
Home will be their safe-heaven as it has always been to me. As long as I can teach them my language, my values, what is important to me, to respect other people and their differences. As long as I can guide them throughout their childhood and why not even their adulthood. As long as I can provide them a safe place to evolve and become whatever they want to be. As long as they can understand that my roots are expanded all around the world and, therefore, theirs will be as well. Then I know they'll be fine. And I'll leave to their father the task of teaching them what it is to belong to one and only one place, because if it depends only on me they'll become citizens of the world. This is what I know and where I come from.
This is my own particular opinion on the subject, but
I would love to hear your side of the story. How do you feel about raising
children in a city/country that is not yours? What are the challenges you
encounter? What about the positive side? And what about the people who are raising their children in their own country, how does it feel? Leave a comment and let’s start a
constructive discussion. What do you think?