Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Marionnettes at the Swedish Cottage - Don't even bother...



This morning, P and I went to see Little Miss Muffet's Monster-Sitting Service, at the Swedish Cottage Marionette Theatre in Central Park, with a friend and her son. The day was beautiful, not too cold and the theatre is one of the most charming places in New York to take kids. Nonetheless, thankfully, our sons were too young to understand the story (the performance is actually recommended for ages 3 to 9). But the older children in the theatre, who were around 5 or 6 years-old were at some point bored (because the story is too complicated and some dialogues are too long) and then even frightened.

The scenarios are very well done, the musics are nice and the crew is really talented. However, the story is completely wrong. From beginning to end. 
Here's why:
  1. A six year-old girl, Molly, arrives home ALONE and finds a message from her parents who have left for the weekend. There's no one at home. Her grand-father is suppose to arrive at some point (from Alaska) to take care of her. But, of course, he doesn't make it, so he sends his old friend a giant spider (that was actually amusing and the spider is one of the best characters). 
  2. There are monsters in the story. If they were funny, that would be alright. But they are not. There is even a dinosaur growling very loud that was quite scary.
  3. There is this malicious  and creepy german monkey that lives in outer space. He's actually Ham, the chimp that was sent to space back in the '50s (if you're interested, here is the footage explaining his mission) and he now wants some revenge by destroying the human race. The Cold War has been over for more than 20 years now, so why do we still need to stereotype the "bad guys" by being Germans?! This should be completely over by now.
  4. The chimp sends a terrible plant that grows during the night into a gigantic and malefic plant and starts to destroy the city (New York). At this point, the curtains are down and we can only hear the sounds of the destruction and people terrified screaming on the top of their lungs and the lights behind the curtains are all red (imagine the reaction of the kids in the theatre). So, little Molly takes command of a huge robot, like a Transformer, and after a ferocious fight destroys the malevolent plant. 
  5. Moral of the story: plants are evil, because they destroy the city; so we should exterminate them. Oh, and let's not forget History, Germans will always be bad. 













I might sound naive, but children are children. Childhood is already such a short period of our life, so why would we want to accelerate it and throw the children into adulthood too early? There are some jokes or some sarcasm that the kids just don't get and that are not appropriate for them. When I go with my children to see something (either a play, or a movie, or a concert) that is for their age, I expect to see content adapted to their age and that's it. Of course, I want to have fun as well. But usually just by looking at their happy faces I'm already spending a good time. And when I want to have fun as an adult, then I call a babysitter and go to the movies with my husband. What I'm trying to say here is that parents have to adapt to their children needs and amusement level and not the other way around. Like we say in French chaque chose en son temps.


We weren't already very convinced about the play last summer (The Secret History of the Swedish Cottage), but this one was a total disappointment. They have the technique, the talent and certainly the imagination. Why can't they just stick to more traditional or children appropriate stories?

Picture of the Swedish Cottage taken from here. And the pictures from the play were taken from Backstage and Time Out New York Kids - the reviews are pretty good, although they agree with me that this is not a great play for children.

8 comments:

  1. Hello people. If you bothered to read what Mrs. Daniela wrote up there and still feel like reading this, kudos to you!

    I thought this review was completely ill founded and unjust. This theatre has been doing the standard fairy tale story time shows for decades. I think, that if they want to branch out and try their hand at modern theatre, good for them. True that some parts of the show were long winded, but I hear they have been fixing it as time goes on. Also, the German monkey is not a reference to any War. No child is going to get that from his character at all. Wasn't Frankenstein a German mad scientist too? By and large he is just silly, and just the right kind of humor for someone 8 or 9. Also, not to give anything away, but he is the character that saves the world at the end and becomes friends with all the other main characters in the show. Truly not an evil character at all.

    Mostly, I wanted to rebuke this scathing review of the show because this isn't just some common production. These people at the cottage OBVIOUSLY worked incredibly hard on this production AND hand-built all the marionettes themselves.

    Yes Marionettes. That is how you spell that word Daniela. Before going to see another Cottage production, you might want to open your eyes a little. Try and see that marionette theatre is incredibly enriching in any form. The Cottage doesn't deserve to be thrown under the bus because they made a risky new production that didn't come out of a Hans Christian Anderson book. This so called "review" doesn't even mention that the songs were up beat and a ton of fun, nor that the hand made marionettes were incredible to look at.

    The truth is, that like Daniela here, most people don't have the intelligence to enjoy work like this. Parents are too engulfed in fear over their child's life experience to take things a little less seriously. World War 2 comes nowhere near this show, and it's absurd to write off this gem like that.

    One more thing. The Cottage is not a daycare center. Tell your children how to behave at a theatre, and maybe they will actually sit and listen long enough to have a good time. This is what my main problem was when I took my 5yr old son to go see it. Don't blame the Cottage if you brought your three year old into a theatrical atmosphere, without bothering to tell them to sit down and shut up, and they never got into the show because they would rather be running around. They are 3. Duh. I myself have worked in theatre and know how true this is.

    Bottom line?
    I liked the show, and I think that someone with ears and eyes will too.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for your comment "Anonymous".
    1- Marionette is derived from French, and it's rightly spelled "Marionnette" in French (sorry, my mistake. But you should agree that juggling between 5 languages everyday is not always easy. Sometimes I'm writing in this blog and then I get distracted and need to write an e-mail in French, or a comment in Portuguese... Anyway I'll try to do better in the future);
    2- I did say that the crew was very talented (actually twice), they are just not good at playwriting. If you are writing a script for children, but you can't hold the patience of a young crowd during the show, then you didn't do your job well;
    3- I never mentioned about my son behavior. He actually didn't scream or made any sound. He sat quietly and concentrated throughout the whole play. He really enjoys theatre and this is certainly not our first puppet or marionette show (if you have the patience you can read some other posts I wrote about that). I was referring to all the other older kids that were there (don't forget that the show is recommended for ages 3 to 9);
    4- I did mention that the musics were nice. What I didn't mention is that the sound wasn't good enough to hear them well;
    5- If the crew, which is extremely talented (I agree 100% with you), wants to try out "modern theatre", they should maybe take a look at what other companies are doing and why they are doing it well (i.e. New Victory Theatre);
    6- I do think that the monkey shouldn't have been German. How do you think a German kid will feel if they go and see that evil monkey? By the way, Frankenstein was invented during the 19th century, when it is well known that there were already some tensions in Europe between Germany, France and England. Maybe you should review your History a little bit. This is exactly my point. Why in 2012 do we still need to do the same mistakes all over again?
    7- Like you, I believe that any kind of theatre is an enriching experience. Again, you may want to read my older posts to understand a little bit about what I usually like to do with my kids. We've been to many plays, puppet shows, concerts, etc. And I'm very proud to tell you, that my kids were ALWAYS very well behaved. This is why I went very enthusiastically to see this new production and, yes, I was very disappointed with the show.
    8- Last but no least, this is a personal blog, where I enjoy writing about my daily activities for the kids. If you didn't like what you read, you could just sign out from here or leave a constructed critic. We may have divergent views on the show, but there are other ways to put that on paper. Obviously, when you say that you had some problems to teach your child to behave, you demonstrated that education is not your best quality.

    Anyway, thank you for your comment. I'm always happy to see that my blog is reaching a bigger audience every day.

    Best,

    Daniela (I like to sign with my name vs. "Anonymous")

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dear Anonumous,
    How sad it is to see bitter people like you. I still can't believe (i) that a mother with brain and culture could enjoy this show and (ii) could attack Daniela's review in such an aggressive and disrespectful way.
    Everyone has the right to enjoy or not whatever they see but certain things are facts and against facts there are no arguments.
    The current show at the Swedish Cottage is ridiculous. I've heard that from a lot of people.
    Lucky them that there are still a couple few like you enjoying the production....Hopefully next one will be more appropriate.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I didn't see the show, but I saw a "grown up" (?) acting like a spoiled child who doesn't accept other people's opinions, and not being brave enough to do as much as show his/her identity. Maybe someone with ears and eyes will like the show, as marionnettes probably do.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I apologize for my comments earlier. I meant to retract what I had written and couldn't. Daniela didnt deserve such criticism. No more than anyone else does for the work they do.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear Anonymous, apologies accepted. Instead of only criticizing my point of view (not very kindly I must say), I would have loved to hear your arguments on why you think the show is great. Like I said earlier and I pointed out on my post, I truly think the crew is talented. The puppets are very well crafted, the scenarios are amazing and the musics are very nice too. However, in my opinion (which thankfully is not the only valid in this world), I still think that the story is the most important thing in a puppet show. I couldn't hear the laughs that we usually hear in children theatre and I saw some bored and then some frightened kids calling for their mothers. If you read the review from Backstage (that I actually linked in my post) they also say that they thought the show was more appropriate for middle-aged women than for children between 3-9 years-old.
      Anyway, I'm happy that some people liked the show and I wish them a lot of success. I also hope that their next program will be nicer than this one. In the meantime, I'll just go to other puppet shows with the kids. We are lucky to live in New York, where there are plenty of options for all tastes and ages.
      Have a good one,
      Daniela

      Delete
  6. I agree Dani, I was so very disappointed with the play last summer at The Swedish Cottage, after hearing great reviews from past plays. My 6 years old didn't like at all, it was such non sense. We LOVE good modern theater, but that was not it.
    I guess they didn't learn from their mistakes? Not sure. Your review was spot on, specially about the sound.

    It is really sad to come to this day and age and see that some people can't handle different opinions than their own and that those people will model that to their kids.

    Love your blog! Beijos

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm a big, big, fan of The Swedish Cottage Marionette Theater.

    I haven't seen this production yet, but I have to say that after reading both, Daniela's review AND Mr Anonymous' comment - I'm not going to waste my time.

    We absolutely used to LOVE their shows (my oldest is 7, so we've been doing it for a while), until last year we went to "The Secret History of the Swedish Cottage", WHAT A DISASTER! It was boooring (as my kids would say), there was absolutely nothing I liked about it, a total disappointment.

    Ok, so you tell me they now want to make "modern theater" - well, their audience is still 3-8 year olds, who really don't get the sarcastic jokes, and all the "modern nonsense". What they like are SIMPLE stories, with a strong MESSAGE behind it - that is why the GRimm/Andersen stories work, even if there is a scary component, it is there for a reason, and not totally random, like the spider or the monkey in this case, from what I hear.

    So if any of the Swedish Cottage people are reading this: please bring back the wonderful, wonderful times back...we miss coming to the shows, we used to watch them 3 ou 4 times each season...

    ReplyDelete